Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza & Grille Sister Bay Menu (Updated October 2025)
Welcome to Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza & Grille Sister Bay, a delightful pizza restaurant nestled in the heart of Sister Bay, Wisconsin. This vibrant eatery offers an enticing menu that celebrates fresh and local ingredients, prepared with a unique wood-fired technique that brings out robust flavors.
The star of the menu is, of course, the wood-fired pizzas. You can't go wrong with the Fun Guy, a delectable blend of five types of sautéed mushrooms, spinach, and caramelized onions over a creamy garlic base—perfect for mushroom lovers at just $23. For a taste of Wisconsin, try the Green & Gold, featuring grilled chicken, bacon, and real Wisconsin cheese curds, paired beautifully with ranch dip.
- Kids Menu: Options like peanut butter & jelly pizza cater to younger guests.
- Dessert: Don’t miss the rich flourless chocolate cake, drizzled with raspberry sauce—a sweet finish for just $9.
Beyond the delicious fare, patrons rave about the friendly service and inviting atmosphere. With outdoor seating available and a charming decor that embraces the local vibe, Wild Tomato is the ideal spot for a casual bite or a family gathering. Whether you’re sharing a pizza with friends or enjoying a quiet dinner, this Sister Bay gem promises a memorable dining experience.
FAVORITES - Favorites
WOOD FIRED BREAD BASKET
A mix of cheesy pesto, parmesan olive tapenade, and basil flatbreads, cheese cracklins, garlic ciabatta, and parmesan knots. Served with marinara, balsamic oil, and herb mascarpone.
US$14.00PARMESAN KNOTS
Fried bread tossed in garlic parmesan seasoning accompanied by house marinara
US$13.00BUFFALO CAULIFLOWER
Baked Cauliflower tossed in Buffalo sauce, served with ranch.
US$12.00FRIED CHEESE CURDS
Hand-battered cheese curds deep-fried to golden brown.
US$12.00CHICKEN TENDERS
Fresh tenders battered and served with french fries & your choice of BBQ sauce or ranch.
US$13.00TERRY’S MAC
Cavatappi pasta tossed with cheddar cheese sauce, topped with cheddar & garlic parmesan.
US$12.00ROASTED TOMATO & BURRATA
Hand-tied burrata, prosciutto, roasted tomatoes, cipollini onions, arugula, and fresh basil drizzled with aged balsamic, olive oil, served with crostini.
US$13.00HUMMUS
Assortment of fresh veggies, lemons, and garlic infused hummus, served with house-made pita bread.
US$14.00Favorites
WOOD FIRED BREAD BASKET
A mix of cheesy pesto, parmesan olive tapenade, and basil flatbreads, cheese cracklins, garlic ciabatta, and parmesan knots. Served with marinara, balsamic oil, and herb mascarpone.
US$14.00PARMESAN KNOTS
Fried bread tossed in garlic parmesan seasoning accompanied by house marinara
US$13.00BUFFALO CAULIFLOWER
Baked Cauliflower tossed in Buffalo sauce, served with ranch.
US$12.00FRIED CHEESE CURDS
Hand-battered cheese curds deep-fried to golden brown.
US$12.00CHICKEN TENDERS
Fresh tenders battered and served with french fries & your choice of BBQ sauce or ranch.
US$13.00TERRY’S MAC
Cavatappi pasta tossed with cheddar cheese sauce, topped with cheddar & garlic parmesan.
US$12.00ROASTED TOMATO & BURRATA
Hand-tied burrata, prosciutto, roasted tomatoes, cipollini onions, arugula, and fresh basil drizzled with aged balsamic, olive oil, served with crostini.
US$13.00HUMMUS
Assortment of fresh veggies, lemons, and garlic infused hummus, served with house-made pita bread.
US$14.00SALADS - Salads
CHERRY WALNUT
Mixed greens, maple roasted walnuts, dried cherries, goat cheese and cherry vinaigrette.
US$13.00CAESAR
Romaine lettuce, house-made Caesar dressing, croutons and Wisconsin parmesan cheese.
US$12.00GARDEN
Mixed greens topped with carrots, tomatoes, sun ower seeds with your choice of dressing.
US$12.00CAPRESE
Fresh mozzarella & sliced heirloom tomato drizzled with olive oil & balsamic vinegar, served with basil at bread.
US$11.00GREEK
Spring mix, kalamata olives, red onions, tomatoes, feta cheese, pepperoncinis, tossed in our house-made Greek vinaigrette.
US$12.00PETITE
Choose between Cherry Walnut, Garden, Caesar, or Greek.
US$8.00FAMILY STYLE
Served in a large wooden bowl, serves four. Choose between Cherry Walnut, Garden, Caesar, or Greek.
US$20.00Salads
CHERRY WALNUT
Mixed greens, maple roasted walnuts, dried cherries, goat cheese and cherry vinaigrette.
US$13.00CAESAR
Romaine lettuce, house-made Caesar dressing, croutons and Wisconsin parmesan cheese.
US$12.00GARDEN
Mixed greens topped with carrots, tomatoes, sun ower seeds with your choice of dressing.
US$12.00CAPRESE
Fresh mozzarella & sliced heirloom tomato drizzled with olive oil & balsamic vinegar, served with basil at bread.
US$11.00GREEK
Spring mix, kalamata olives, red onions, tomatoes, feta cheese, pepperoncinis, tossed in our house-made Greek vinaigrette.
US$12.00PETITE
Choose between Cherry Walnut, Garden, Caesar, or Greek.
US$8.00FAMILY STYLE
Served in a large wooden bowl, serves four. Choose between Cherry Walnut, Garden, Caesar, or Greek.
US$20.00PIZZA - Small Pizza
SMALL CREATE YOUR OWN
Hand-tossed dough, shredded mozzarella and smoked provolone cheeses, over our house recipe organic tomato sauce.
US$15.50SMALL HALF & HALF
SELECT TWO SPECIALITY PIZZAS. EACH SPECIALITY WILL BE ON HALF OF THE PIZZA.
US$23.00SMALL D-LUX
Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, red and green peppers with extra cheese.
US$23.00SMALL SAUSAGE & PESTO
Our famous house-made Italian sausage with fresh diced tomatoes, fresh basil and pesto.
US$23.00SMALL VEGGIE
Red and green peppers, onions, mushrooms, artichoke hearts, sun dried tomatoes, pesto, Wisconsin goat cheese with special cheese blend.
US$23.00SMALL BUFFALO CHICKEN RANCH
Crispy chicken, spinach, red onions, bacon, over a creamy ranch base, finished with buffalo drizzle.
US$23.00SMALL THE GREEN & GOLD
Grilled chicken, bacon, grilled broccoli and spinach. Topped with REAL Wisconsin cheese curds. Ask for some ranch for dipping to be a true fan.
US$23.00SMALL THE FUN GUY
Five types of sauteed mushrooms, spinach, and caramelized onions, over a garlic cream base.
US$23.00SMALL MARGHERITA
Buffalo mozzarella, fresh basil, and olive oil, over a crushed tomato base.
US$21.00SMALL OLD SCHOOL
Grilled chicken and caramelized onions, over a savory BBQ base, finished with fresh cilantro.
US$23.00SMALL MEDITERRANEAN
Grilled chicken, roasted tomatoes, yellow peppers, kalamata olives, artichoke hearts, fresh mozzarella, and parmesan, over a pesto base.
US$23.00SMALL PAISANO
Italian sausage, soppressata, red onions, calabrese peppers, and pesto.
US$23.00SMALL CARNE ASADA
Carne asada, chihuahua cheese, red onions, fresh jalapenos, over a salsa verde base, finished with cilantro and an avocado-crema drizzle.
US$23.00SMALL HOT HONEY
Pepperoni, goat cheese, mozzarella, spinach, and red onions, over our original sauce base, finished with a sweet and spicy hot honey drizzle.
US$23.00SMALL DONATION CREATION
Carne asada, chihuahua cheese, red onions, fresh jalapenos, over a salsa verde base, finished with cilantro and avocado-crema drizzle. This month’s beneficiary is Standing Strong For Chris Hecht Fund
US$23.00PIZZA - Large Pizza
LARGE CREATE YOUR OWN
Hand-tossed dough, shredded mozzarella and smoked provolone cheeses, over our house recipe organic tomato sauce.
US$19.50LARGE HALF & HALF
SELECT TWO SPECIALITY PIZZAS. EACH SPECIALITY WILL BE ON HALF OF THE PIZZA.
US$27.00LARGE D-LUX
Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, red and green peppers with extra cheese.
US$27.00LARGE SAUSAGE & PESTO
Our famous house-made Italian sausage with fresh diced tomatoes, fresh basil and pesto.
US$27.00LARGE VEGGIE
Red and green peppers, onions, mushrooms, artichoke hearts, sun dried tomatoes, pesto, Wisconsin goat cheese with special cheese blend.
US$27.00LARGE BUFFALO CHICKEN RANCH
Crispy chicken, spinach, red onions, bacon, over a creamy ranch base, finished with buffalo drizzle.
US$27.00LARGE THE GREEN & GOLD
Grilled chicken, bacon, grilled broccoli and spinach. Topped with REAL Wisconsin cheese curds. Ask for some ranch for dipping to be a true fan.
US$27.00LARGE THE FUN GUY
Five types of sauteed mushrooms, spinach, and caramelized onions, over a garlic cream base.
US$27.00LARGE MARGHERITA
Buffalo mozzarella, fresh basil, and olive oil, over a crushed tomato base.
US$25.00LARGE OLD SCHOOL
Grilled chicken and caramelized onions, over a savory BBQ base, finished with fresh cilantro.
US$27.00LARGE MEDITERRANEAN
Grilled chicken, roasted tomatoes, yellow peppers, kalamata olives, artichoke hearts, fresh mozzarella, and parmesan, over a pesto base.
US$27.00LARGE PAISANO
Italian sausage, soppressata, red onions, calabrese peppers, and pesto.
US$27.00LARGE CARNE ASADA
Carne asada, chihuahua cheese, red onions, fresh jalapenos, over a salsa verde base, finished with cilantro and an avocado-crema drizzle.
US$27.00LARGE HOT HONEY
Pepperoni, goat cheese, mozzarella, spinach, and red onions, over our original sauce base, finished with a sweet and spicy hot honey drizzle.
US$27.00LARGE DONATION CREATION
Carne asada, chihuahua cheese, red onions, fresh jalapenos, over a salsa verde base, finished with cilantro and avocado-crema drizzle. This month’s beneficiary is Standing Strong For Chris Hecht Fund
US$27.00PIZZA - GF Small Pizza
GF SMALL CREATE YOUR OWN
Hand-tossed dough, shredded mozzarella and smoked provolone cheeses, over our house recipe organic tomato sauce.
US$19.45GF SMALL HALF & HALF
SELECT TWO SPECIALITY PIZZAS. EACH SPECIALITY WILL BE ON HALF OF THE PIZZA.
US$26.95GF SMALL D-LUX
Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, red and green peppers with extra cheese.
US$26.95GF SMALL SAUSAGE & PESTO
Our famous house-made Italian sausage with fresh diced tomatoes, fresh basil and pesto.
US$26.95GF SMALL VEGGIE
Red and green peppers, onions, mushrooms, artichoke hearts, sun dried tomatoes, pesto, Wisconsin goat cheese with special cheese blend.
US$26.95GF SMALL BUFFALO CHICKEN RANCH
Crispy chicken, spinach, red onions, bacon, over a creamy ranch base, finished with buffalo drizzle.
US$26.95GF SMALL THE GREEN & GOLD
Grilled chicken, bacon, grilled broccoli and spinach. Topped with REAL Wisconsin cheese curds. Ask for some ranch for dipping to be a true fan.
US$26.95GF SMALL THE FUN GUY
Five types of sauteed mushrooms, spinach, and caramelized onions, over a garlic cream base.
US$26.95GF SMALL OLD SCHOOL
Grilled chicken and caramelized onions, over a savory BBQ base, finished with fresh cilantro.
US$26.95GF SMALL MEDITERRANEAN
Grilled chicken, roasted tomatoes, yellow peppers, kalamata olives, artichoke hearts, fresh mozzarella, and parmesan, over a pesto base.
US$26.95GF SMALL PAISANO
Italian sausage, soppressata, red onions, calabrese peppers, and pesto.
US$26.95GF SMALL MARGHERITA
Buffalo mozzarella, fresh basil, and olive oil, over a crushed tomato base.
US$24.95GF SMALL CARNE ASADA
Carne asada, chihuahua cheese, red onions, fresh jalapenos, over a salsa verde base, finished with cilantro and an avocado-crema drizzle.
US$26.95GF SMALL HOT HONEY
Pepperoni, goat cheese, mozzarella, spinach, and red onions, over our original sauce base, finished with a sweet and spicy hot honey drizzle.
US$26.95GF SMALL DONATION CREATION
Carne asada, chihuahua cheese, red onions, fresh jalapenos, over a salsa verde base, finished with cilantro and avocado-crema drizzle. This month’s beneficiary is Standing Strong For Chris Hecht Fund
US$26.95Small Pizza
SMALL CREATE YOUR OWN
Hand-tossed dough, shredded mozzarella and smoked provolone cheeses, over our house recipe organic tomato sauce.
US$15.50SMALL HALF & HALF
SELECT TWO SPECIALITY PIZZAS. EACH SPECIALITY WILL BE ON HALF OF THE PIZZA.
US$23.00SMALL D-LUX
Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, red and green peppers with extra cheese.
US$23.00SMALL SAUSAGE & PESTO
Our famous house-made Italian sausage with fresh diced tomatoes, fresh basil and pesto.
US$23.00SMALL VEGGIE
Red and green peppers, onions, mushrooms, artichoke hearts, sun dried tomatoes, pesto, Wisconsin goat cheese with special cheese blend.
US$23.00SMALL BUFFALO CHICKEN RANCH
Crispy chicken, spinach, red onions, bacon, over a creamy ranch base, finished with buffalo drizzle.
US$23.00SMALL THE GREEN & GOLD
Grilled chicken, bacon, grilled broccoli and spinach. Topped with REAL Wisconsin cheese curds. Ask for some ranch for dipping to be a true fan.
US$23.00SMALL THE FUN GUY
Five types of sauteed mushrooms, spinach, and caramelized onions, over a garlic cream base.
US$23.00SMALL MARGHERITA
Buffalo mozzarella, fresh basil, and olive oil, over a crushed tomato base.
US$21.00SMALL OLD SCHOOL
Grilled chicken and caramelized onions, over a savory BBQ base, finished with fresh cilantro.
US$23.00SMALL MEDITERRANEAN
Grilled chicken, roasted tomatoes, yellow peppers, kalamata olives, artichoke hearts, fresh mozzarella, and parmesan, over a pesto base.
US$23.00SMALL PAISANO
Italian sausage, soppressata, red onions, calabrese peppers, and pesto.
US$23.00SMALL CARNE ASADA
Carne asada, chihuahua cheese, red onions, fresh jalapenos, over a salsa verde base, finished with cilantro and an avocado-crema drizzle.
US$23.00SMALL HOT HONEY
Pepperoni, goat cheese, mozzarella, spinach, and red onions, over our original sauce base, finished with a sweet and spicy hot honey drizzle.
US$23.00SMALL DONATION CREATION
Carne asada, chihuahua cheese, red onions, fresh jalapenos, over a salsa verde base, finished with cilantro and avocado-crema drizzle. This month’s beneficiary is Standing Strong For Chris Hecht Fund
US$23.00Large Pizza
LARGE CREATE YOUR OWN
Hand-tossed dough, shredded mozzarella and smoked provolone cheeses, over our house recipe organic tomato sauce.
US$19.50LARGE HALF & HALF
SELECT TWO SPECIALITY PIZZAS. EACH SPECIALITY WILL BE ON HALF OF THE PIZZA.
US$27.00LARGE D-LUX
Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, red and green peppers with extra cheese.
US$27.00LARGE SAUSAGE & PESTO
Our famous house-made Italian sausage with fresh diced tomatoes, fresh basil and pesto.
US$27.00LARGE VEGGIE
Red and green peppers, onions, mushrooms, artichoke hearts, sun dried tomatoes, pesto, Wisconsin goat cheese with special cheese blend.
US$27.00LARGE BUFFALO CHICKEN RANCH
Crispy chicken, spinach, red onions, bacon, over a creamy ranch base, finished with buffalo drizzle.
US$27.00LARGE THE GREEN & GOLD
Grilled chicken, bacon, grilled broccoli and spinach. Topped with REAL Wisconsin cheese curds. Ask for some ranch for dipping to be a true fan.
US$27.00LARGE THE FUN GUY
Five types of sauteed mushrooms, spinach, and caramelized onions, over a garlic cream base.
US$27.00LARGE MARGHERITA
Buffalo mozzarella, fresh basil, and olive oil, over a crushed tomato base.
US$25.00LARGE OLD SCHOOL
Grilled chicken and caramelized onions, over a savory BBQ base, finished with fresh cilantro.
US$27.00LARGE MEDITERRANEAN
Grilled chicken, roasted tomatoes, yellow peppers, kalamata olives, artichoke hearts, fresh mozzarella, and parmesan, over a pesto base.
US$27.00LARGE PAISANO
Italian sausage, soppressata, red onions, calabrese peppers, and pesto.
US$27.00LARGE CARNE ASADA
Carne asada, chihuahua cheese, red onions, fresh jalapenos, over a salsa verde base, finished with cilantro and an avocado-crema drizzle.
US$27.00LARGE HOT HONEY
Pepperoni, goat cheese, mozzarella, spinach, and red onions, over our original sauce base, finished with a sweet and spicy hot honey drizzle.
US$27.00LARGE DONATION CREATION
Carne asada, chihuahua cheese, red onions, fresh jalapenos, over a salsa verde base, finished with cilantro and avocado-crema drizzle. This month’s beneficiary is Standing Strong For Chris Hecht Fund
US$27.00GF Small Pizza
GF SMALL CREATE YOUR OWN
Hand-tossed dough, shredded mozzarella and smoked provolone cheeses, over our house recipe organic tomato sauce.
US$19.45GF SMALL HALF & HALF
SELECT TWO SPECIALITY PIZZAS. EACH SPECIALITY WILL BE ON HALF OF THE PIZZA.
US$26.95GF SMALL D-LUX
Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, red and green peppers with extra cheese.
US$26.95GF SMALL SAUSAGE & PESTO
Our famous house-made Italian sausage with fresh diced tomatoes, fresh basil and pesto.
US$26.95GF SMALL VEGGIE
Red and green peppers, onions, mushrooms, artichoke hearts, sun dried tomatoes, pesto, Wisconsin goat cheese with special cheese blend.
US$26.95GF SMALL BUFFALO CHICKEN RANCH
Crispy chicken, spinach, red onions, bacon, over a creamy ranch base, finished with buffalo drizzle.
US$26.95GF SMALL THE GREEN & GOLD
Grilled chicken, bacon, grilled broccoli and spinach. Topped with REAL Wisconsin cheese curds. Ask for some ranch for dipping to be a true fan.
US$26.95GF SMALL THE FUN GUY
Five types of sauteed mushrooms, spinach, and caramelized onions, over a garlic cream base.
US$26.95GF SMALL OLD SCHOOL
Grilled chicken and caramelized onions, over a savory BBQ base, finished with fresh cilantro.
US$26.95GF SMALL MEDITERRANEAN
Grilled chicken, roasted tomatoes, yellow peppers, kalamata olives, artichoke hearts, fresh mozzarella, and parmesan, over a pesto base.
US$26.95GF SMALL PAISANO
Italian sausage, soppressata, red onions, calabrese peppers, and pesto.
US$26.95GF SMALL MARGHERITA
Buffalo mozzarella, fresh basil, and olive oil, over a crushed tomato base.
US$24.95GF SMALL CARNE ASADA
Carne asada, chihuahua cheese, red onions, fresh jalapenos, over a salsa verde base, finished with cilantro and an avocado-crema drizzle.
US$26.95GF SMALL HOT HONEY
Pepperoni, goat cheese, mozzarella, spinach, and red onions, over our original sauce base, finished with a sweet and spicy hot honey drizzle.
US$26.95GF SMALL DONATION CREATION
Carne asada, chihuahua cheese, red onions, fresh jalapenos, over a salsa verde base, finished with cilantro and avocado-crema drizzle. This month’s beneficiary is Standing Strong For Chris Hecht Fund
US$26.95KIDS - Kids Menu
PEANUT BUTTER & JELLY PIZZA
US$8.00KIDS MAC
US$8.00NOODLES
With Marinara sauce or butter
US$8.00Kids Menu
PEANUT BUTTER & JELLY PIZZA
US$8.00KIDS MAC
US$8.00NOODLES
With Marinara sauce or butter
US$8.00DESSERT - Desserts
NY STYLE CHEESECAKE
With Door County cherries
US$9.00FLOURLESS CHOCOLATE CAKE
Decadent chocolate with raspberry sauce
US$9.00DESSERT KNOTS
Fried bread tossed in cinnamon sugar seasoning accompanied by pumpkin cream sauce.
US$9.00Desserts
NY STYLE CHEESECAKE
With Door County cherries
US$9.00FLOURLESS CHOCOLATE CAKE
Decadent chocolate with raspberry sauce
US$9.00DESSERT KNOTS
Fried bread tossed in cinnamon sugar seasoning accompanied by pumpkin cream sauce.
US$9.00Extra Menu Picks
- El Trio Loco Menu 3615 US-101, Gearhart, OR 97138, United States
- J's Fish and Chicken Market Menu 5412 Prospect Ave, Kansas City, MO 64130, United States
- Alvarado Street Brewery Taproom Menu 301 Main St, Salinas, CA 93901, United States
- Island Joes Coffee and Gallery Menu 14829 S Padre Island Dr, Corpus Christi, TX 78418, United States
- Tony Harper's Pizza & Clam Shack Menu 3062 NY-28, Old Forge, NY 13420, United States
- Chretin's Mexican Food Menu 505 E 16th St, Yuma, AZ 85365, United States
- Sabor Latino Menu 8047 Asheville Hwy, Spartanburg, SC 29303, United States
- ebisu sushi Menu 2513 W Taron Ct #180, Elk Grove, CA 95757, United States
- Eastern Memories Menu 21 North St, Cannock WS11 0BB, United Kingdom
- Bouquet Restaurant Menu 519 Main St, Covington, KY 41011, United States